Saturday, October 13, 2018

Two Thomases

This post has nothing directly about music, but my mandate, "classical music, popular culture, philosophy and anything else that catches my fancy..." is pretty broad. I'm titling it "Two Thomases" because both names came up in a dinner party last night. There was an old British tv comedy called "The Two Ronnies."

The first Thomas is Thomas Sowell who recently retired after a long career as an economist, writer and educator. The photo accompanying the Wikipedia article is very, very old, so:


He has a doctorate in economics from the University of Chicago, which means he is loosely in the "Chicago School of Economics" as opposed to being a Keynesian or, you know, a socialist. He is eighty-eight years old and just recently retired, though he is still a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution. He has written a host of books of which perhaps the most generally useful is his Basic Economics, which is as clear-headed and sensible discussion as one could hope to find. In the new edition of the work, there are some new chapters one of which talks about why there are such great economic inequalities in the world:
Any study of international economic activities inevitably encounters the fact of vast differences among nations in their incomes and wealth. In the early nineteenth century, for example, there were four Balkan countries where the average income per capita was only one-fourth that in the industrialized countries of Western Europe.{ 847} Two centuries later, there were still economic differences of a similar magnitude between the countries of Western Europe and various countries in the Balkans and Eastern Europe. The per capita Gross Domestic Product (GDP) of Albania, Moldova, Ukraine and Kosovo were each less than one-fourth of the per capita GDP of Holland, Switzerland, or Denmark— and less than one-fifth of the per capita GDP of Norway.{ 848} Similar disparities are common in Asia, where the per capita GDP of China is less than one-fourth that of Japan,{ 849} while that of India is barely more than ten percent of the per capita GDP of Japan. The per capita GDP of sub-Saharan Africa is less than ten percent of the per capita GDP of the nations of the Euro zone.{ 850} Many find such disparities both puzzling and troubling, especially when contemplating the fate of people born in such dire poverty that their chances of a fulfilling life seem very remote. Among the many explanations that have been offered for this painful situation, there are some that are more emotionally satisfying or politically popular than others. But a more fundamental question might be: Was there ever any realistic chance that the nations of the world would have had similar prospects of economic development? Innumerable factors go into economic development. For all the possible combinations and permutations of these factors to work out in such a way as to produce even approximately equal results for all countries around the world would be a staggering coincidence. We can, however, examine some of these factors, in order to get some insight into some of the causes of these differences. 
Sowell, Thomas. Basic Economics (pp. 527-528). Basic Books. Kindle Edition.
The book has no graphs and no highly technical discussion, just a good introduction to economics from a common sense viewpoint. Sowell has written a lot of other books on cultural and social issues as well so you might have a look around.

The other Thomas is an utterly different kind of person. Thomas Merton I became acquainted with a few decades ago, partly through the influence of a religious friend of mine.


I got the idea for writing this post because I was surprised to find that no-one at my dinner party had ever heard of Thomas Merton--and they were all, to some extent, religious people. If you read the Wikipedia article, as you should, you will find that Merton was one of the great spiritual figures of the 20th century. In 1948 he published a memoir of his path to the faith, The Seven Storey Mountain. I found it a fascinating read, though it that was long ago and I should probably re-read it. Merton spent most of his life as a Trappist monk whose vocation was, basically, to write books. Ones that I read and found interesting include The Wisdom of the Desert in which he delves into the Christian desert fathers of the 4th century and finds some interesting parallels with Zen masters!

I hope you take a bit of time and look into either or both of this writers as they are likely both worth the effort.

10 comments:

Will Wilkin said...

On Garrison Keeler's Prairie Home Companion radio show a few years ago, I heard a joke that struck me as very true: Q: Do you know the difference between an international economist and a circus clown? A: (after silence) Me neither.

I read Merton's Asian Journal (the last things he wrote, published after he died of electrocution in Thailand I think it was) and, I think it was called Zen and the Birds of Appetite. He made a big impression on me when I was about 18 years old, I bet he'd make an equally big new impression if I were to read him now. Hmmmm...I have a copy of his Seven Story Mountain handy but have never yet read it.

Marc in Eugene said...

I spent several years of my life as a Carthusian converse brother. The story told was that Thomas Merton tried out life en chartreuse but that 'the chartreuse spit him out'-- as one might have expected, given the arc of his life. (It took much longer for me to be spit out.) For all I know, the trope about the monastery spitting out those who have no vocation is ancient and not confined to the Carthusian world.

Bryan Townsend said...

Glad this post provoked a couple of comments. Economists are like any other group, there are good ones and bad ones. I think Sowell is an example of a good one. Paul Krugman, on the other hand...

A friend of mine was a novice monk of some kind, but never took his final vows. I guess he was "spit out." I thought Merton's vocation as a writer was pretty successful?

Will Wilkin said...

Hi Marc, I confess I drink Chartreuse several nights a week, made by the Carthusian brothers. Probably my favorite libation in the world, and I spend the money to keep it in stock. My experience with monastic life is limited to an annual retreat hosted by the Passionist order at Holy Family Retreat House in West Hartford, CT USA.

Bryan Townsend said...

Every month or so I set aside time to open a nice bottle of Bourgogne or other fine wine--last week it was an excellent Châteauneuf-du-Pape--and this is partly in honor of fine economists like Thomas Sowell. Heh! I used to have a girlfriend that was a big fan of Benedictine.

Marc in Eugene said...

Will, The next important question is, green? or yellow? :-) My recollection, and it and they all grow dimmer with each passing year, is that we enjoyed a glass (two or three ounces, perhaps, a 'double shot') of the green Chartreuse in the refectory at the principal solemnities of the year, oh, nine or ten times a year. I like it well enough but can't enjoy the yellow, which is terribly sweet. The elixir is of a higher alcohol content even than the green and more herb-y, and was reserved by Father Prior to be given out as medicament when one of the brothers was feeling poorly.

Bryan, I haven't read any Merton in many years but from what I see his literary reputation has stood the test of time, and he lived a fascinating life, certainly. From the point of view of the monastic virtue of stability, however, being grounded in one monastery, rooted in one community, in one place, for life, his monastic career was open to a certain criticism. Have never read a serious biography.

Bryan Townsend said...

Looking at Amazon I see that there are six or seven biographies of Merton. It might be interesting to have a look. A certain reluctance comes from the recent trend in biographies to be muckraking even when there is little muck to rake.

Marc in Eugene said...

And what muck there is is so often only of the variety 'who she did or did not have sex with and how he/she/they all felt about their relationships'. Very tiresome (that is the one area of human life where we most all of us actually have experiences!!) except in one in ten thousand cases: either the subject has to be truly outstanding or the biographer has to be a truly excellent writer.

Bryan Townsend said...

I don't read many biographies other than monographs on composers. Indeed, the life stories that stick in my mind were all autobiographies: Phillip Glass' memoir, Arthur Rubinstein's book on his early life, Winston Churchill's on his early life, T. E. Lawrence's Seven Pillars of Wisdom about his time in the Middle East and most of all Robert Graves' memoir Goodbye to All That. I guess all of those fulfill your two requirements!

Will Wilkin said...

Marc, I'm only on my 2nd bottle, and both have definitely been green. I will be excited to try the yellow if it ever comes around, though since I've been on a very low carb lifestyle I find sweetness where never before I could detect it, and already the Green Chartreuse is to me almost sickly sweet. I pour a shot or two in the night, when after a full day's labor plus fatherhood and household duties I finally settle in to play the viola da gamba I bought just 2 months ago. Oh how those deep warm resonant bass tones mix with those deep warm strong distilled botanicals! And while I'm talking to you, I thank you for your thoughtful comments here from time to time. You are one of the commenting readers who make Bryan's blog for me even more enrichening.