![]() |
| Pianist Yuja Wang |
When I was trying to advance my career, the older artists such as Narciso Yepes and Julian Bream each had very much their own personality reflected not only in their phrasing but also in tone color. But even with my generation there was starting to be a sameness rigidly enforced by the need to win competitions. The robotic repetitive industrial aspect of the music 'industry' comes out in biographies that all read virtually the same with just different names. Interpretations are standardized. Tone color is very similar. And the same narrow repertoire is everywhere.
But occasionally one runs across a genuinely individual artist outside of the usual haunts. That brings us to the English guitarist Steven Watson whom I have been following for a few years. He is a committed no-nails guitarist. At first his clips on YouTube were short pieces, often off the beaten path. Then he started putting up performances on unusual instruments like banjo, lute, and ukulele. Here are a few of those clips. Tarrega on gut strings:
Paul McCartney's Yesterday arranged by Toru Takemitsu:
Telemann on 7-string banjo:
And lurking out there somewhere is his cover of the Buffy the Vampire Slayer theme.
But his latest is so unusual it forces us to consider him from an entirely different angle: as a truly creative musician and composer. This is all 1 hour and 20 minutes of Ad Infinitum, which I strongly encourage you to listen to in its entirety--you won't want to miss the moment of stagecraft where he adjusts his glasses around the one hour mark.
This seems to breathe the influence of Morton Feldman's very long pieces of chamber music like his six hour String Quartet or Violin and String Quartet (2 hours). But the texture also strongly reminds me of one of the strangest pieces by Bach, his Canon per Augmentationem in Contrario Motu from The Art of Fugue where the comes arrives after four measures, in double note values, down a fifth and in inversion. The austere effect is very similar to Steven's piece. It might also share some musical DNA with Eric Satie's Vexations, a short piano piece with a lot of tritones which is to be played, if I recall correctly, eight hundred times...


11 comments:
Goodness, well I'm extremely flattered. Of course, I've been following you for even longer, Bryan! YouTube can be a blessing. It's great for reaching the truly interested. And it's much easier to be 'experimental', as there's no cost and mostly it takes little time (at least the slapdash no-fuss no-edit way I do it...)
What a splendid line: 'you won't want to miss the moment of stagecraft where he adjusts his glasses around the one hour mark.' I have to find a way to quote that.
840 times for Vexations! I had the mad dream the other night of a live performance of Ad Infinitum that does indeed go on infinitely, with many musicians doing shifts... There is that John Cage organ piece that is scheduled to end in 600 years, but they're using mechanical organ, which seems like cheating, really.
There is a good number of guitarists doing genuinely interesting things at the moment. I'm very taken, for example, with Laura Snowden's recent composition for guitar quartet: https://youtu.be/qbikVT2DDk0?is=Zj5elKwmJ6FA258M
I'm so glad you noticed the post! Now we just need a whole bunch of comments. YouTube, despite the annoying commercial interruptions, really is an amazing resource. Unfortunately few take advantage of it to be experimental. It is heavily skewed towards those attracted by the commercial possibilities. Thanks for the tip about Laura Snowdon. I will have a listen!
And Steven, keep doing what you are doing!
Perhaps becuase, like with the superseding of blogs by Substacks etc., YouTube has been professionalised. The amateur culture -- I mean this in the best, older sense of 'amateur' -- that it had before is getting proportionally smaller and smaller.
I suspect that aspect of amateur culture in arts and entertainment on Youtube could be described as hobbyist or also as a continuation of what in American entertainment history was called the vaudeville circuit from a century ago.
There's a comics artist and writer who goes by youngrippa who remarked recently that a surprisingly (and disconcertingly) amount of YT content these days is REACTION or COMMENTARY content and not as much of it is new material. In a way with AI data mining and scraping that's not entirely a surprise but it's an element about Youtube that seems to have changed in the last ten years, maybe not for the better--so preserving Youtube elements where people create and share things rather than doing metacultural punditry is nice to still have.
Just to generalize a bit, the notional amateur nature of what Steven is doing, or myself for that matter, is in part a reaction to the seeming corruption of professional authority which seems widespread. Creativity comes from the outside these days, not from the inside, and perhaps it always has.
The parasitic reaction video... It's a good point. They often seem to get quite a bit more traffic than the things they are commenting on.
I wouldn't describe amateurs as hobbyists necessarily. There are some contemporary reviews in which Fernando Sor was complimentarily described as an amateur. It had pure and uncorrupted associations. That's more what I meant by it, as Bryan says. It doesn't necessarily mean that the work is less good and skilful, as 'hobbyist' implies. British orchestral choruses, such as the London Symphony Chorus (who sing with the London Symphony Orchestra), are entirely amateur. Might Charles Ives or Trollope be considered amateurs...?
belated thought, Bryan, remember back when Hilary Hahn parted ways with Sony and decided to record the Schoenberg violin concerto and the outfit she wore for the cover was the dowdiest dress she could find? :) The usual suspect pianists seem more like outliers than norms for the industry. It's not like Helena Grimaud did any flashy costume stuff for that recording of Bartok she was on (all of us who have that recording know she wasn't even ON the cover because it was Boulez conducting the Bartok piano concerti)
Steven, you allude to a good point about the changing status of the amateur in arts criticism and arts journalism over the last few centuries.
C. S. Lewis somewhere said something like "true excellence is never showy." The meaning of the word professional has changed even over the course of my career. I used to have deep respect for those musicians that I thought of as "professional." They were the ones that spent the necessary hours polishing and perfecting the performance to a high standard. But recently professionalism has taken on a different aura: the professionals are the ones that will do anything for commercial advantage, are hypocritical, are always chasing market advantage, while the so-called "amateurs" are the ones simply pursuing some aesthetic vision with no regard for commercial success.
The Telemann and Tarrega arrangements sound noticeably better than the others because the music allows more idiomatic guitar fingering. I would point to the Renaissance intablatures of more "popular" songs of the day particularly from Northern Italy or France. They are often quite wild though instrumentally idiomatic and do not strive for close correspondence to the original material.
the recently posted Carl Ruggles homage for banjo was fun
Agreed!
Post a Comment