Friday, November 24, 2023

Friday Miscellanea

New edition of Tárrega

Yuri Temirkanov:

As head of two of Russia’s leading musical institutions, the Kirov (later, Mariinsky) Opera and Ballet Theatre (1976-88) and the Leningrad (later, St Petersburg) Philharmonic Orchestra, of which he was principal conductor for more than three decades from 1988, Yuri Temirkanov, who has died aged 84, was at the forefront of music in the Soviet Union for nearly half a century.

I saw Temirkanov conduct the St Petersburg Philharmonic in a concert in Valencia a few years ago. In that post I said:

I mentioned that the Saint Petersburg Philharmonic only takes on a new musical director on rare occasions. From 1938 to 1988 they were directed by Yevgeny Mravinsky, famous for his sober and restrained conducting style. Regarding the orchestra, David Fanning remarked:

The Leningrad Philharmonic play like a wild stallion, only just held in check by the willpower of its master. Every smallest movement is placed with fierce pride; at any moment it may break into such a frenzied gallop that you hardly know whether to feel exhilarated or terrified.

So, rather than furiously provoking them into playing as so many modern conductors do (*cough* Dudamel *cough*), Mravinsky had to hold them back. Their current conductor, Yuri Temirkanov, who took over from Mravinsky in 1988 and is still at the helm, has a bit of the same style. No baton, conducts with sober movements, occasionally looks as if he is about to dig a trench, and then a moment later is beckoning gently for more lyricism.

So, Mravinsky was music director for fifty years but Temirkanov only lasted for thirty-five years. One thing you can say, no conductor ever retires from the St Petersburg Philharmonic. in the last eighty-five years they have only had two conductors!

* * *

The dire state of music education: Don’t stop the music

Music degrees are expensive to provide. They often require performance spaces, practice rooms, studios, equipment and technicians, instruments, and extra staff for instrumental and vocal teaching and ensemble direction. Of course, science degrees also require costly labs, facilities and technicians, but there is a wider range of government grants available for STEM subjects. Music is considerably more resource-intensive than non-performing arts and humanities subjects, many of which require little more than individual lecturers and spaces for lectures and seminars. Cutting a music programme can represent a significant saving for universities facing financial difficulties. 

At the same time, the sector itself cannot be wholly absolved of responsibility. In the name of “decolonisation”, the study of classical music is regularly impugned, associated with imperial domination, white supremacy, elitist hegemony and more; a glance at a range of leading conferences or journals makes clear how well-established such perspectives are.

It is impossible to summarize that article, so read the whole thing.

* * *

We seem to have a remarkable number of neglected black female composers. Her Music Fell Into Obscurity. Now It’s Back at the Philharmonic.

For Perry, a Black composer who died in 1979 at age 55, the 1950s and ’60s were replete with success, the summit of a career that fell into obscurity despite musicians’ admiration of her work. The mezzo-soprano J’Nai Bridges, who will make her Philharmonic debut on Wednesday performing in the “Stabat Mater” solo part, said of the piece: “I love the vocal writing. It’s intense, it’s very introspective, it’s very intimate and also very extreme.” Dima Slobodeniouk, who will conduct the program, described it as “logically and beautifully written.”

* * *

My last trip to Europe was so challenging that I decided to hold off on long flights for a while. I'm going to spend a few days in Mexico City in a couple of weeks. And then I ran across this article: The world’s best cities for culture. Number one is Mexico City.

Mexico’s charismatic, cosmopolitan capital nabbed the top spot, with locals scoring their city exceptionally high for both the quality and affordability of its culture scene. And while architecture, theatres and street parades like Dia de Muertos all got the nod in our survey, it was the city’s mighty museum scene that got the biggest shout-out. CDMX’s museums showcase everything from Aztec artifacts and folk art to surrealist paintings, and many of them are housed in showstopping buildings – just check out the grand, neo-baroque Palacio de Bellas Artes or the twisty, shiny and ultra-modern Museo Soumaya. Best of all? Many are either permanently free or offer free entry on Sundays for those with Mexican residency.

Yes, all that is true, but I have yet to find much in the way of classical music concerts--or maybe I just don't know where to look. 

* * *

Sparse content this week so let's curate some envois. First up the very fine Chinese guitarist Xuefei Yang with Ian Bostridge in a fine performance of the Songs from the Chinese by Benjamin Britten. You can watch the whole thing, which includes an interview with Xuefei Yang, but the Britten starts at the 38:48 mark:

Here is the Stabat Mater by Julia Perry, written in 1951.

Francisco Tárrega seems to be enjoying renewed popularity these days. There is a lovely new complete edition by Les Productions d'Oz and lots of performances. When I was a student I played the shorter pieces and got into the habit of thinking of him as a composer of little bon-bons. And Recuerdos de la Alhambra was too difficult! But of course he wrote lots of great concert pieces among which Capricho Arabe is one of the best. Here is a recording by Segovia:

We have to end with Temirkanov and the St Petersburg Philharmonic. I can't find the Glinka overture they began with in Valencia, which was truly terrifying, but here is the Symphony No. 4 of Tchaikovsky:


4 comments:

  1. Thanks for noticing the Julia Perry Stabat Mater! I listened for about five or six minutes when I saw that article earlier in the week and was distracted and never finished: now I've had the stimulus needed to get back to it.

    The second thought that crossed my mind, whenever I got to that Perry article, was, 'ah, perhaps I get to add a new Stabat Mater to the website!'-- but ought to have known that it had already been done. The Ultimate Stabat Mater Website is perhaps niche (there are over 300 of them) but one can wander into all sorts of exotic places.

    The Pace article is scary and I'm sure that the UK is in much better shape than most places in the US.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for the link to the Stabat Mater Website, Marc.

    Re the article by Ian Pace, a few clips from Elon Musk interviews popped up on YouTube recently (for me, anyway) and in one of them he comments on education that anyone can learn anything they want for free. He doesn't think there is much need for higher education, or even high school. Those places offer a social experience and credentials. He for one, never hires anyone based on their credentials, at least the traditional ones. Mind you, musical training really does benefit from being in close proximity with other musicians for inspiration and collaboration and a traditional music department is a good place to find all that. They also might make you spend time on some useful things that you would not do on your own. But too often music departments fall into the hands of pompous, bureaucratic careerists, the bane of all institutions.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Well, there is a certain sort of fellow who will watch a series of twelve videos by former doctoral student and current YouTube creative Ms Explicatorix (for free! although he did... do such people still have 'virtual tip jars'?) in which she unveils the mysteries of 16th century London dialects and then feel himself in Musk-like command of his subject. Surely a well-run school offers much more than 'a social experience and credentials'? I get the impression that EM happily envisages a society of atoms bouncing around on their own paths, unconstrained by any potential consideration superior to the satisfaction of their own atom-ness. Cassiodorus, Alcuin and John Henry Newman would turn over in their graves.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The give-away phrase there is "well-run." Sadly all too many institutions of higher learning are not in fact well-run, but are delivering the worst sort of ideas into minds of the poor students.

    ReplyDelete