My CD arrived remarkably quickly so this will be the first of a few posts on this admirable project. First, a comment on the cover design:
Over the course of the last 18 months, I've come to think of this project as an anthology, a snapshot in time, documenting a tiny slice of the creative thought and output in this country today. I invite you to stop listening to pundits, extend your ears, open up your imagination, and trust the music to guide you into a challenging, complicated and thrilling sound world--This Is America. --Johnny Gandelsman
The booklet also contains an essay by each composer on their piece, plus the words to those pieces with a text and a track listing.
I apologize if I am a "pundit" though I think of myself more as being a (retired) performer and very part-time composer. So let's work our way slowly through these 22 pieces. The first one is"O" (standing for "oxygen") by Clarice Assad. She sees oxygen as a common theme in the transmission of Covid, the respiratory failure that it often caused, the prevention of breath entering the lungs of George Floyd and so on. "O" is for violin and processed vocal overdubs. Blogger won't embed, but here is a clip from YouTube from the album:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tPk6s8fWBoI
Clarice Assad is the daughter of Sergio Assad of the famous Assad guitar duo. This piece makes excellent use of the violin's capacity for extended, expressive melody. I don't have too much to say after only listening a couple of times, but it seems a very effective piece with a lot of atmospheric weight. There is also a clip on YouTube where she talks briefly about the piece:
That's all I am going to do today. I encourage you to pick up a copy of the album and we can work our way through it together.
I will probably explore this as per your suggestion because it is Bryan T. recommending it but I admit to being on the defensive. I just don't think socially instructive music works; that is, the instructions (for social betterment) don't hold across time and music just does not surrender to ideas (or ideals). The "O" theories of Miss Assad strike me as so much beans and rice. My message to composers is the same as Hemingway's to writers: If you got to send a message go to Western Union.
ReplyDeleteMy slow moving survey of the album has obviously been interrupted by my trip to Europe (which did not go as intended!) but the plan is to work my way through the whole album in a scrupulously neutral way and then offer some critical comments at the end. In general I agree with you: music should have musical goals, not socially instructive ones. The question is, is there anyone left still holding those ideals, or are all the artists swept up in the crusade?
ReplyDelete