* * *
My greatest disappointment this year was being unable to attend the Salzburg Festival--a disappointment shared by music critic Jay Nordlinger who nonetheless gives a chronicle based on listening to some concerts from the much-abbreviated festival online:
Andrew Manze, the Englishman, conducted an all-Mozart concert. The orchestra was a local band, and a very good one: the Mozarteum Orchestra of Salzburg. Its principal horn, Rob van de Laar (a Dutchman, as his name tells you), was the soloist in the Horn Concerto No. 2 in E flat. The pianist Francesco Piemontesi (another man whose name gives his origin) was the soloist in the “Coronation” Concerto. These two soloists are elegant and skilled players. About Manze’s Mozart conducting, I have rhapsodized before. He is a brainy musician and a natural, friendly leader who takes great pleasure in Mozart. So do the players under his baton. You can see it in their faces (as well as hear it in their playing).
What a gift, this conducting, and this music, and music in general—never more than in a screwy, sorrowful, dislocating time.
This was given in the Grosse Saal of the Mozarteum where I attended another Mozart concert last year. Here is a link to that post.
* * *
The Times Literary Supplement asks if it is time to sound An elegy for handwriting?
Is it time to compose an elegy for handwriting? Anne Trubek thinks so – indeed, hopes so. She deems the ability to form a cursive script “merely emblematic”, and dreams of a future in which the school curriculum will include it only for art classes. It will remain solely the domain of calligraphers such as Patricia Lovett, who is herself probably Britain’s best-known practitioner, teacher and advocate. Lovett’s latest book is a gorgeously presented survey of the work of masterly scribes from the third century AD to the twenty-first, culminating, appropriately (and with no false modesty), with her own work. Though Lovett would undoubtedly baulk at such a description, her volume constitutes, in Trubek’s logic, an alluring swansong of an “antiquated” skill.
I think that handwriting might be undergoing a small renaissance due to the current rage for "journaling" whether in bullet form or not. Writing down one's thoughts, goals, musings, projects and accomplishments in a journal rather than in some digital format makes it all more concrete and lasting somehow.
* * *
Things seem to be going backwards in Europe with rising infection levels prompting governments in France and the Netherlands to shut down concerts for the next month.
* * *
The Nation has an interview with John Luther Adams who is, apparently, a "legend." John Luther Adams’s Songs for a Vanished World.
Adams: Musically, I came of age in a time when there was this ongoing war between smart music and pretty music. And one of the things that I discovered was that it’s a false dichotomy. Music can be intellectually airtight and still sock you in the belly or grab you by the ears or seduce you, ravish you. So it brought me back to this idea that music is all about sound. And the mysterious power of sound to touch us and move us and make us more fully human in ways that perhaps nothing else can.
* * *
Igor Levit won the Instrumental Recording of the Year at Gramophone Magazine for his Beethoven Sonata Cycle.
* * *
Alex Ross has a piece at The New Yorker about The Hidden Costs of Streaming Music.
Listening to music on the Internet feels clean, efficient, environmentally virtuous. Instead of accumulating heaps of vinyl or plastic, we unpocket our sleek devices and pluck tunes from the ether. Music has, it seems, been freed from the grubby realm of things. Kyle Devine, in his recent book, “Decomposed: The Political Ecology of Music,” thoroughly dismantles that seductive illusion. Like everything we do on the Internet, streaming and downloading music requires a steady surge of energy. Devine writes, “The environmental cost of music is now greater than at any time during recorded music’s previous eras.” He supports that claim with a chart of his own devising, using data culled from various sources, which suggests that, in 2016, streaming and downloading music generated around a hundred and ninety-four million kilograms of greenhouse-gas emissions—some forty million more than the emissions associated with all music formats in 2000. Given the unprecedented reliance on streaming media during the coronavirus pandemic, the figure for 2020 will probably be even greater.
Do you ever get the feeling that progressive environmentalism will not be happy until they have forced all of us to return to pre-civilization levels of energy use? Have you heard the joke "What did progressives use for light before candles? Electricity."
* * *
The Los Angeles Review of Books has a review of a troubling book: The Great Unread: On William Deresiewicz’s “The Death of the Artist”
EARLY IN HIS new book, The Death of the Artist: How Creators Are Struggling to Survive in the Age of Billionaires and Big Tech, William Deresiewicz relates two stories often told about the arts today. From Silicon Valley and its boosters, we hear: “There’s never been a better time to be an artist.” Anyone can easily market their own music, books, or films online, drum up a thousand true fans, and enjoy a decent living. We see proof of this, time and again, in profiles of bold creators who got tired of waiting to be chosen, took to the web, and saw their work go viral.
The artists tell another tale. Yes, you can produce and post your work more easily, but so can everyone else. Every year, every major venue — SoundCloud, Kindle Store, Sundance — is inundated with thousands if not millions of songs, books, and films, but most sink like a stone. Of the 6,000,000 books in the US Kindle Store, the “overwhelming majority” of which are self-published, “68 percent sell fewer than two copies a month.” Only about 2,000 US Kindle Store authors earn more than $25,000 per year. Spotify features roughly 2,000,000 artists worldwide, but less than four percent of them garner 95 percent of the streams. The pie has been “pulverized into a million tiny crumbs.” We may now have “universal access” to the audience, but “at the price of universal impoverishment.”
You should read the whole thing. The review goes on to note that the narrative described in the first paragraph turns out to be pure propaganda--the second paragraph describes the reality. The truth is that if you are spending most of your time on networking and promoting your "art" is likely to be little more than shallow entertainment. And why would we be surprised at that?
* * *
Let's have a couple of envois to chase away our tears after that last article. Here is Gianluca Capuano conducting the Mozarteumorchester with Julia Lezhneva at the Salzburg Festival 2020:
And here is the 7th concert in Igor Levit's cycle of all the Beethoven piano sonatas, also from the Salzburg Festival this year:
I picked up the Deresiewicz on Kindle recently and plan to read it. I've been sufficiently intrigued by other stuff he's written in the past I figured I'd give this new book of his a try. Will, I hope, have more things to say about it after I've read it.
ReplyDeleteIf you do a review of it, we would love to hear about it.
ReplyDeleteI listened to the Levit cycle both at Salzburg (via the streaming at Arte) and then again to... I don't recall which parts, precisely, but four or five of them, at the Berliner Festspiele (via the Berlin Philharmonic site)-- a wonderful experience although I don't go out of my way to listen to the sonatas very often. I 'visited' with Levit quite frequently on Facebook, back in April and May (?), when he was livestreaming a daily recital. Stopped because I got tired of the woke homilies he delivered himself of, which I'm sure delighted most of his listeners, however, and doubtless solidified his position in the pantheon. No denying the powerful performances, though.
ReplyDeleteNext year at Salzburg, perhaps!
YouTube is truly encyclopedic in its recordings but I noted a lacuna earlier: I couldn't find Rodion Shchedrin's Beethoven's Heiligenstädter Testament. A commission in 2008 by the Bavarian Radio, maybe it simply has never been performed again (although there is a 2015 BR-Klassik album where it appears-- they would have an interest in recording it, after all). There's a concert in Tallinn this morning in which it will be performed by the Estonian National Symphony. Had never heard of it and have no particular interest in Shchedrin's work but my curiosity has been piqued. :-)
Great Fri Misc 'como de costumbre' as they say in Mexico.... Khatia Buniatishvili ....?
ReplyDeleteYes, Dex, sadly no new news on costuming for Yuja Wang or Khatia Buniatishvili.
ReplyDeleteMarc, I heard Levit play the Diabelli Variations last year, but have only listened to a couple from the new sonata cycle. Mind you, have had his late sonatas CD for a couple of years. I find his interpretive ideas very interesting and fresh.
Marc, how about this?
ReplyDeletehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jeJuwT-0DW0
It's an auto-generation of the BR-Klassik album but it's been up since 2014 and was auto-generated by Youtube. It's got the slightly weird tongue-in-cheek over the top with tiny hints of pathos and bathos I tend to expect from the composer.
I've got Shchedrin's 24 preludes and fugues in score and by way of Shchedrin's recording. It has its ups and downs but since I'm sort of into fugal cycles from Soviet and former Soviet bloc composers I found the
Shchedrin worthwhile study.
Book 1
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-0KH-wDfTlc&t=2426s
Book 2
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=28vD4Jmnyck
Thank you, Wenatchee. Between my eyes and my sometimes over-indulged impatience I missed that; that album is also at Spotify. And this is all good because either I dozed off yesterday and missed the Shchedrin on the radio or else I misread or misinterpreted the Estonian and they hadn't been intending to broadcast the entire concert. Enjoyed the Beethoven's Heiligenstädter Testament and do want to listen to more of his piano music, sooner or later. I don't know about the operas, though.
ReplyDelete'Auto-generation'-- have always wondered how that works at YT; the sense is that (in this case) BR-Klassik itself uploaded the CD? as opposed to me uploading that surreptitious recording I made on my mobile last night? Do I have that right?
I stumbled across this earlier today; who knew there is a Polish Royal Opera (since 2017).
ReplyDelete... (T)he Polish Royal Opera strives for the magnificence for which the Chapel Royal at the courts of the Polish Vasa kings was famous. On the other hand, the impressive building of the Royal Theatre in the Łazienki Park is a reminder the flourishing of the opera during the reign of the King Stanisław August Poniatowski... (a)t present, this is the main stage of the Polish Royal Opera, an institution whose mission is to cultivate and popularize Polish musical heritage, and to build and strengthen the Polish and European identity focused around the three Platonic ideals: Truth, Goodness, and Beauty.
This must be the sort of thing that the Euroleft is talking about when they go on about 'fascism corrupting Poland'.
Our demand that all of musical history should be available at the touch of a finger has become gluttonous. It may seem a harmless form of consumer desire, but it leaves real scars on the face of the Earth.
ReplyDeleteAlex Ross is going to pry that 'entire musical history' (not that it is that, obviously) out of my cold, dead hands. I wonder which of the other vices he is concerning himself with these days.
I like that! You can take the glories of the history of music from me when you pry them from my cold, dead hands.
ReplyDeleteIs it my imagination or is there a real resistance to the resistance slowly taking shape?
Just finished watching a livestream from Warsaw, a concert version of Cherubini's 1806 comic opera Faniska (based on an 1803 play called Les mines de Pologne by the once-famous René-Charles de Pixerécourt). Some of the soloists and orchestra wore masks, many didn't. All the artists were well-distanced, even though this made the final bows a bit laughable, watching the gowned ladies tripping through unnatural routes between the musicians. I'm know this isn't news to anyone who reads here but we could be doing this in the US. Not that _Faniska_ would be on anyone's program.
ReplyDeleteAnd I learned that Cherubini composed an opera (1813) based on Chateaubriand's Les Abencérages.
Thanks for this, Marc. It is very good to hear. Yes, in Europe they are, with a bit of a struggle, managing to put on concerts and even operas. But I was just talking on Facetime to my ex who lives near Dresden and there is a lot of concern about the rising infection rates in Europe, which are now exceeding those in the US.
ReplyDeleteThe main reason that they can do this in Europe and don't seem to be able to do it in North America is that European governments offer MASSIVE subsidies that make it possible.
The Oregon Bach Festival sent out its October Update today, which is chiefly 'we're working on things'. There will be a livestreamed performance by Simone Dinnerstein in December of An American Mosaic, 15 miniatures for the piano by Richard Danielpour-- 'about us and the plague', words to that effect, and we get free access! to a series of livestreams from the Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center... which, so far as I can tell, are also free to those countless others who don't get email updates from the OBF.
ReplyDeleteThey've also made a playlist on Spotify! for our delectation, including two "odes to Pharaoh" from Handel's Joseph and His Brethren, which aren't 'odes to Pharoah' at all and so rouse my suspicions about someone's seriousness. One is the 'Grand March' from Part I, which I suppose by some stretch of the imagination could be described as 'glorification of the Pharoah's regime'. The other is precisely the aria in which Joseph (slave, foreigner, Jew) identifies the significance of Pharoah's dreaming.
Oh, and they've hired two new people to their 'development staff'.
I do realize it is much easier to make critical observations than to produce a series of concerts etc etc.
No, "odes to Pharaoh" don't sound very appropriate to an oratorio about Joseph!
ReplyDeleteI was talking to the president of our society, which is kept in the black solely with patron's donations, and he shared with me that they could only put on the season this year by accepting the loss of quite a significant amount. But he deemed it worthwhile so as not to lose our audience.
https://www.instagram.com/p/CGpth_lhswN/
ReplyDeleteMozart really knew how to write for the soprano voice!
ReplyDeleteJulia Lezhneva has a wonderful voice! I broke down a few months ago and succumbed to the mystique of the iPad; don't actually use it all that much but it's great for watching videos on Instagram.
ReplyDeleteAnd if you plug some good headphones into the iPad, it can be fantastic. Also, great for reading books on with the Kindle Reader.
ReplyDelete