Only one artist has actually recorded all of these sonatas, the very gifted harpsichordist Scott Ross, who passed away tragically young. This is him playing the Sonata K. 27 in B minor:
Here is guitarist John Williams playing my favorite sonata, K. 213 in D minor:
Composer/guitarist Leo Brouwer has recorded some of the most creative performances of Scarlatti sonatas. This is K. 206 in E major:
Going back to the keyboard, here is a very zippy performance of K. 141 in D minor by Martha Argerich:
And finally, returning to the harpsichord, this is Gustav Leonhardt with K. 227:
As Steven mentions in his blog post, Scarlatti, while greatly admired by both composers and performers, does not fit easily into the standard narrative. His musical imagination and style lies rather out of the mainstream, partaking of both Baroque and Classical elements without being firmly in either camp. As one writer noted in passing, Scarlatti was perfectly capable of inventing Classical style in a sonata or two, and then putting it aside to do something else! As W. Dean Sutcliffe mentions in his book (linked to by Steven), the critical landscape regarding Scarlatti is a vacant one. To put it bluntly, almost no work has been done in the critical appraisal and examination of Scarlatti's music.
But we can still enjoy it!
Bryan, just a quick technical correction Dutch harpsichordist Pieter-Jan Belder has also recorded the complete sonatas available in a box on the Brilliant Classics label. I think this project was completed some years after Ross'. Belder's project features a number of different harpsichords (and I think maybe even a fortepiano or two). I agree that the collection is a rich mine of musical brilliance and enjoyment.
ReplyDeleteYou are so right, David! I was just checking and it seems there are complete collections by Richard Lester and Zuzana Ruzicková as well! But I have the Scott Ross on my shelf.
ReplyDeleteIf I may put a word in for the Andreas Staier recordings. The least reserved, the least genteel -- I sometimes find other recordings too dull now.
ReplyDelete(And thank you for the shout out!)
Yes, some fine Scarlatti from Andreas Staier!
ReplyDeleteYou're welcome.
My favorite Scarlatti has always been Alessandro, father of Domenico. I love his sweet vocal music. He supposedly composed over 500 cantatas! The few I've heard are among my favorite music ever. And his Mass for Saint Cecilia (Patron Saint of Musicians) is rightly in the repertoire.
ReplyDeleteThe Domenico sonatas for harpsichord are very enjoyable, and I've been told many require great virtuosity to play. I recall reading in some concert program notes that he pretty much improvised a lot of them and then went back and wrote them down.
You know, I have never listened to much by Alessandro Scarlatti! Sounds like I should.
ReplyDeleteBack in the mid-1980s I heard some recitals by guitarist Elliot Fisk, and bought some of his records, including some of his own transcriptions for guitar of baroque music written for other instruments. At edges of my memory I think I read in program notes that he trained at Yale under the founder of the guitar program at YSM who had created a repertoire by transcribing harpsichord music, being suitable due to both sounding by plucking strings.
ReplyDeleteRegarding Alessandro Scarlatti, if you like baroque opera (a special love of mine) then you will love his cantatas. His vocal music sounds to me like the bridge between Monteverdi and Handel.
I met Elliot Fisk at Pepe Romero's masterclass in Salzburg in the 80s. He has now taken over that class.
ReplyDelete