Showing posts with label Schoenberg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Schoenberg. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Clarity and Obscurity

To a composer, the Bach two-part inventions are models of, well, invention. Here is an example:


Now that's how to write two independent voices with imitation. There is also a lot of invertible counterpoint. That's when you write passages where you can flip the two voices so the upper becomes the lower. It isn't quite as easy as it sounds. These were written for teaching purposes by Bach and are still used today. Even people who could care less about Bach-style counterpoint make use of the basic idea.


I think you can hear the way the vocal melody rises and then falls in waves, while the independent bass line descends. Paul came up with a lot of great bass lines. The reason I mention this is that I've noticed a trend towards obscurity. It may have begun with the third movement of this piece, which starts at around 7:04:

This is the third of Schoenberg's Five Pieces for Orchestra, op 16 entitled "Farben" (colors). It uses a newly-devised technique called "klangfarbenmelodie" or "sound-color-melody". The basic idea is to replace clear melodic counterpoint with changing instrumental colors. This and the other pieces in op 16 are very interesting in their own way. But. In the hands of more ordinary composers it becomes mush. There was a reason Bach taught his students counterpoint. And that Beethoven studied Bach's counterpoint. And that Chopin never went anywhere without a copy of the Well-Tempered Clavier. Finally we end up with something like this:


That really sounds like it is about to do something, or mean something, but it never does. This is called 'ambient' music and it originates with Brian Eno. It may have a function, but... Here is something similar by the Icelandic "post-rock" group Sigur Ros:


The problem I have with this is that there is no clarity: everything becomes a wash of sound with occasional fragments floating out. You can't really hear what's going on and you probably aren't supposed to. You are just supposed to float in the ocean of sound, lapping back and forth. Personally, I hate it! Obscurity is not a virtue in my book. Unless! Unless it is for a reason. I guess that makes it an 'instrumental' virtue. Something that may be of use to some other end. In itself obscurity is just ... bad. Here is something that uses ambiguity for good effect:


Now that music is going somewhere!

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Harmony Revisited, Part 1

More and more, when I'm thinking about what is right or wrong with a piece of music, it is harmony that seems to be in question. The unrelenting dreariness of a lot of the music written between 1920 and 1960 is really a problem of harmony. The "emancipation of the dissonance" meant that the 'harmony' was always the same. Instead of the age-old principle of dissonance--resolution we just had dissonance--dissonance. How could that possibly work?
I choose this Bach chorale, not for its emotional content, but simply as an example of real harmony. The many chorales of Bach were collected soon after his death and published for the use of musicians, mostly composers. There have been several editions, but in one form or another, the collection has been in print since 1765. I would suspect that nearly every composer has a copy. Bach was a crucial figure in the move towards the system of tuning we use today: equal temperament. In order to make full use of the possibility of modulation, every key had to be usable. In the older tuning systems the key of C major was perfectly in tune, but a key like A flat major would be horribly out of tune. Equal temperament solves the problem. The period from Haydn to Beethoven made full use of this freedom of modulation. Here is another example of harmonic mastery:
The basic principle of harmony was the tension between dominant and tonic. Here Beethoven manages to be clearly in the key of A major while avoiding landing on it as much as possible. This gives the harmony a floating feeling as opposed to the solidity of Bach's harmony. The tonic/dominant tension was extended with secondary or applied dominants and the extremely useful devices of mixture (using harmonies borrowed from the minor in major keys and vice versa), the diminished seventh chord (which, due to its symmetry can go in any direction), the augmented sixth chords (which sound like a dominant, but actually prepare a different dominant) and the Neapolitan, which is a clever way of modulating to an unexpected key. The opening of "The Tempest" sonata by Beethoven shows his kind of harmonic thinking:
The harmonic 'system'--if we can call it that--of the Classical Period offered an incredible array of harmonic possibilities both flexible and powerful. The music of Haydn, Mozart and Beethoven is inconceivable in the absence of the harmonic system they used to such miraculous effect. Alas, after the death of Beethoven in 1827, it began to collapse as composers began to dilute the basic relationships to the point where the tensions gradually disappeared in a morass of chromaticism. Composers like Chopin, also a remarkable harmonist, began using remote harmonies just for their color without the preparation that Beethoven would have found necessary:
Throughout the 19th century, harmony becomes more and more of a problem and some started to think that it needed to be completely replaced by a different system. The main candidate was Schoenberg's 12-tone method that uses all the possible notes in a specific order, subjected to contrapuntal treatment. So the whole axis of consonance/dissonance disappears. Here is an example:
Though there is much to be said for this music--especially in terms of its suitability to the times--it has not been accepted by audiences except in small doses. One critic said that Schoenberg could empty any concert hall. I think the problem comes back to harmony. This music is all dissonance.

In another post I will take up what followed the atonal phase and the attempts by the minimalist and process composers to reinvent harmony.